Will Jim Hiller’s Lack of Trust in Gavin McKenna Cost Him His Job?

Jim Hiller is already under pressure in Toronto, and his decision not to use Gavin McKenna in overtime has given Maple Leafs fans another reason to question his judgment. The team is losing, the offence is struggling, and one of its most gifted young players can’t get on the ice when there’s open space to create something.

That seems like a strange choice, especially given what three-on-three hockey offers a player like McKenna. The Maple Leafs have played four overtime games this season and won only one. They’ve managed just one goal in more than 18 minutes of three-on-three play. That’s not exactly a situation where the coach should be afraid to try something different.

Why Keep McKenna on the Bench?

Hiller explained that he wants McKenna to be ready for those situations. There’s some logic to being careful with an 18-year-old rookie. The NHL is a big jump, and coaches shouldn’t automatically give a young player every difficult assignment just because he has talent.

But overtime is different. Three-on-three creates open ice. Fewer players to get around, more room to carry the puck, and more opportunities for a skilled player to make something happen. There are also fewer of the crowded board battles and traffic situations that can make life difficult for a young player.

McKenna’s biggest strength is his ability to create offence. Why wouldn’t Hiller want to give him a chance to use it? The defensive risk is real. A mistake in overtime can end the game. But the Maple Leafs aren’t exactly making much happen with the players Hiller has been using. At some point, playing it safe becomes its own problem.

Is This Another Sign Hiller Has Lost the Room?

Adam Gretz at Yardbarker points out that San Jose has given Ivar Stenberg, selected one spot behind McKenna, more than 13 minutes of overtime ice time. The Sharks are willing to let their young player learn in those situations. That doesn’t mean McKenna should be handed every important minute. But he should at least get an opportunity.

And that’s where this becomes another question about Hiller’s judgment. The Maple Leafs are on an eight-game losing streak, and the coach is under growing scrutiny. His decisions are under closer scrutiny because the results aren’t there.

Would this one decision cost Hiller his job? Probably not by itself. But it adds to the impression that he’s coaching cautiously when Toronto needs someone willing to take a chance. If McKenna can’t get an opportunity in three-on-three overtime, it’s fair to ask when Hiller thinks the right time will come.

Related: Cutter Gauthier Is Chasing NHL History. Is This Just the Start?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *