There’s something appealing about the idea of Teoscar Hernández coming back to Toronto. Not because the Blue Jays need to relive the past, but because they could use a little of what Hernández brought when he was here: power, personality, and the feeling that somebody in the middle of the lineup might change a game with one swing.
According to reports, the Blue Jays have maintained interest in a reunion with the former Toronto slugger. That possibility makes sense when you look at where the offence finished in 2026. Toronto ranked last in home runs, runs scored, and RBIs. That’s not a small problem to fix with a couple of lineup adjustments.
Hernández Put Up Some Huge Numbers with the Blue Jays
Hernández spent six seasons with the Blue Jays and was an All-Star in 2021, when he hit 32 home runs and drove in 116 runs. He also has a history of power, hitting at least 29 home runs each season from 2021 through 2025.
Of course, there’s another side to this story. Hernández is now 34, coming off a season in which hamstring problems limited him to 125 games. He hit just 16 home runs and drove in 64 runs. The Dodgers may be ready to move on, particularly with young outfield prospect Josue De Paula looking for a bigger opportunity.
For Toronto, the question isn’t whether Hernández was a good Blue Jay. We already know that. The question is how much of that hitter remains.
The Blue Jays Have Struck Out Before with Veteran Sluggers
And that’s where the Blue Jays need to be careful. The Anthony Santander signing reminds us that adding an established power hitter doesn’t automatically mean adding an established power hitter’s production. Age, injuries, and the demands of a long season can complicate those plans.
Still, a reunion with Hernández could offer something worth considering. He’s entering the final guaranteed year of his contract, with a $15 million club option for 2028 and a $6.5 million buyout. That could make him a shorter-term commitment than some of the other available bats.
Toronto doesn’t need to make a sentimental decision. It needs to make a sensible baseball decision. But sometimes those two things can point in the same direction. Hernández knows the organization, knows the city, and has already shown Blue Jays fans what he can bring to a lineup.
The familiar face isn’t necessarily the answer. But given what Toronto needs, he’s certainly worth another look. And who’s to say he wouldn’t have a positive impact like his former teammate Vladimir Guerrero Jr.? If his personality could get Vlady going again, that would be a big benefit in itself.
Related: Bo Bichette Has $42 Million Reasons to Stay in New York. But Is Money the Whole Story?
