Sometimes a football game comes down to one play. Saturday’s game between Michigan and UCLA took three overtimes to decide, but the biggest story may have had very little to do with the final score. Michigan won 18-16 when Bryce Underwood found Jalen Hoffman for a two-point conversion. It was a terrific finish for the Wolverines, but UCLA may have come away with a much bigger problem.
The Bruins had arrived with a 10-0 record and a real chance to make some noise in the College Football Playoff. Then quarterback Ty Dieffenbach went down with an injury on the first play of overtime. He had already helped UCLA get back into the game, leading a fourth-quarter touchdown drive that tied the score with just 10 seconds remaining. Now, his availability for what comes next is a major question.
Give Michigan Credit for Wrestling Out a Win Against an Unbeaten Team
Michigan deserves credit for finding a way to win. Underwood was making his first start since October 17, and while his passing numbers weren’t spectacular, he helped get the job done. Running back Savion Hiter also had a strong night, carrying the ball 26 times for 104 yards. Michigan’s freshman kicker Jacob Baggett made two field goals in overtime, and the Wolverines eventually got the conversion they needed.
But the game also showed how quickly things can change for a team that has been having a special season. UCLA had struggled offensively for much of the night, but when it needed a score, Dieffenbach led a 15-play, 77-yard drive to tie the game. That’s what good teams need from their quarterback. They need someone who can find a way when the game is on the line. Losing that player at this stage of the season is hard to overcome.

Losing Dieffenbach Gave UCLA a Difficult Problem
The Bruins’ backup, Madden Iamaleava, had very little experience coming into the game. He completed no passes in overtime, and UCLA’s offence looked uncertain without Dieffenbach. Coach Bob Chesney said afterward that the team trusts Madden, but trusting a young quarterback and asking him to lead a playoff contender are two different things.
Michigan will remember this as a dramatic home victory. UCLA may remember it as the night its season took an unexpected turn. The Bruins entered the weekend looking like a strong playoff contender. Now, even if they get there, they have to wonder whether they have enough at quarterback to make a run.
That’s the hard part of college football. A season can be built over months, and sometimes the difference between a dream finish and a disappointing one is a single injury.
Related: Georgia Is Still No. 1, but Who’s Starting to Make a Move?

