Davis Schneider is one of those players Blue Jays fans have taken a liking to. The moustache, the energy, and the way he burst onto the scene in 2023 made him an easy player to cheer for. But baseball is a business, and sometimes a player popular with fans becomes one a team has to consider moving.

That’s where Schneider finds himself as the Blue Jays head into the offseason. There has reportedly been early trade interest, and while moving a fan favourite is never easy, there are reasons Toronto might listen.

Schneider Hasn’t Had Much Room to Play

The biggest issue is that Schneider hasn’t established himself as an everyday player. His 2026 season was a difficult one offensively. He hit .145 with five home runs and a .310 on-base percentage in 69 games. He also struck out in 32.7 percent of his plate appearances.

Those aren’t the numbers that make a player untouchable. Schneider also spent much of the season moving between the major-league club and the minors, making it hard to find a consistent role.

The Blue Jays have some roster decisions coming, too. With players like Josh Smith and Brett Bateman making an impression, and Anthony Santander and Addison Barger expected to be part of the picture, Schneider may have fewer opportunities for regular playing time. Sometimes a player needs a change of scenery, particularly when another organization can give him a bigger opportunity.

There Is Still Something to Like About Schneider

On the other hand, Schneider hasn’t forgotten how to hit. His arrival in 2023 was something special. He became just the fourth player in Blue Jays history to hit a home run in his first major-league at-bat. He followed that with nine hits, including two home runs, over his first three games. Those early numbers created some pretty high expectations. He also has experience at several positions, and that versatility can be useful for a team looking for help off the bench.

Schneider is projected to make approximately $1.3 million through arbitration, and he still has minor-league options. That makes him a relatively inexpensive player for a team willing to take a chance. The Boston Red Sox have reportedly shown interest, which is an interesting possibility given his history against them.

If the Blue Jays Get a Good Return, They’ll Consider Moving Schneider

The Blue Jays don’t have to trade Schneider just because someone asks about him. But they should consider what they could get in return and whether that would help them improve the roster.

Fans might not be thrilled to see the moustache go somewhere else. Still, sometimes a move that makes sense for the organization isn’t necessarily the move fans want to see.

Related: So, What Does It Take to Win a Cy Young Award These Days?