I watched the three-hour YouTube video This Coach NEVER PUNTS! The NICK SABAN Of High School Has His Own Reality Show! expecting to be drawn into the football. I was, especially when the games began. But when I finished watching, I found myself thinking less about the fourth-down decisions and more about the coach making them.

Kevin Kelley built a remarkable football program at Pulaski Academy High School in Little Rock, Arkansas. An opening image showed players holding a plaque marked “State Championships 2003,” the year Kelley became head coach and led the team to a state title. He went on to win eight more state championships there. Several of his players advanced to NCAA football, and even NFL coach Bill Belichick admired Kelley’s unconventional approach. His story reminds us that high school decisions can reach well beyond the field.

The Pressure of Going Against Conventional Wisdom

Something about Kevin Kelley’s visible tension stayed with me. As I watched, I wondered what it must be like to build a reputation around challenging conventional wisdom, knowing every decision could be celebrated as brilliant or replayed as a mistake. I couldn’t quite settle my thoughts, and perhaps that’s why I kept thinking about the show.

I should be careful here. I don’t know Kelley, and a television program can’t tell me what someone is thinking. Editing shapes what we see, too. I can only describe my impression of what I watched, not claim to know what was happening inside the coach’s head.

Still, I was struck by a possible contradiction. A coach can make bold decisions without being fearless. In fact, going against convention might bring its own particular pressure. When a gamble works, the coach looks like a visionary. When it fails, the decision can become the story, replayed and debated long after the game is over.

How Do We Judge Decisions in Sports?

That raises an interesting question about how we judge people in sports. We celebrate the coach who trusts the numbers, the competitor who wants the ball, or the player willing to take a risk. But do we think enough about the responsibility that comes with those choices?

Kelley challenged two deeply rooted football habits. He almost never punted on fourth down, and he routinely attempted onside kicks. His reasoning came from analytics. He believed the numbers supported taking those risks, and he was willing to test that belief.

Going for it on fourth down might be the right decision even when it fails. Punting might be the conventional choice and still turn out badly. The result doesn’t always tell us whether the decision was sound. Yet results are what fans see on the scoreboard, and what critics can use to make their case.

I’m still not sure what to make of the tension I thought I saw. Maybe I was reading too much into a few scenes. Maybe the pressure was simply part of the job. I don’t know.

But the documentary left me with a question worth carrying beyond football: Is courage the absence of fear, or is it making a decision you believe is right while knowing you may have to answer for it afterward?

I finished the video without settling that question. Perhaps that’s what made it worth watching.

Related: Will Stein Has Kentucky Rolling. Can the Wildcats Meet Expectations?