If Mitch Marner truly wanted to stay with the Maple Leafs in Toronto—and everything suggests that at one point, he did—you have to wonder if, years from now, he’ll look back and ask himself whether it was all worth it. Not the goals or the points or the All-Star nods. But the friction—the tension that never really went away after that drawn-out contract negotiation.

He got his money, but did it cost him something deeper?

Might Hindsight Come Back to Bother Marner?

Hindsight has a way of sharpening the edges. Maybe one day he’ll reflect on the pressure, the scrutiny, and ask whether—for a million or two less—he might’ve bought himself something more lasting: a better connection with the city. A softer spotlight. A longer runway.

Because in the end, how many toys can one man buy? How many luxury cars, watches, or beach vacations before you wonder if pride clouded judgment?

Might Marner Have Handled the Media and Fans Better?

What Marner never quite said—and maybe never let himself say—was something simple and human: “I could’ve been better. I didn’t come through when it mattered. That’s on me.” A moment of humility like that might’ve gone a long way. Might’ve softened his image. Might’ve made fans see him not just as a talent, but as a teammate in the struggle.

Instead, he remained guarded. And now, it’s hard not to ask: Did the division between Marner and the fanbase have to become so wide? Did it have to become a question of us versus him? Or—given the right tone and words—could it have been avoided?

Beyond Being a Maple Leafs Fan, I’m Sad for Marner

Regret is a quiet thing. It shows up late, uninvited, in the rearview mirror. And maybe, one day, could Marner see a version of this story that could have unfolded differently—if only the conversation between player and city had taken a more humble turn.

Although I’m close to turning 80, I’ve never had the chances of notoriety that Marner has had. Still, I can reflect on similar incidents and wonder how I might have done it better. I wonder if Marner will do the same. If so, that would be a sad story indeed. I have to believe it all could have been avoided.

Related: Wise Maple Leafs’ Move: PTOs Instead of Trade Deadline Veterans