Before the regular season began, many questions surrounded the Toronto Maple Leafs’ goaltending situation. With a pair of goalies—Joseph Woll and Anthony Stolarz—who lacked playoff experience between the pipes, many experts and fans wondered if Toronto’s crease would hold up under the bright lights of the postseason.
In last night’s Game 1, Stolarz helped the team win 6-2. He rewarded the coaching staff’s faith with a composed 31-save effort. He robbed Brady Tkachuk on a breakaway and made key stops during Ottawa’s power plays. He held the fort when the Senators pushed hard at the start of the second period.
As a result, in a playoff series full of emotion and chaos, Stolarz brought exactly what Toronto needed: quiet confidence and timely saves. He never looked rattled, not even when Ridly Greig crashed into him late in the game. It was a performance that solidified his grip on the net, at least for now.
Toronto took a risk, and Anthony Stolarz Made It Look Genius
As Game 1 of the playoffs is now in the books, the Maple Leafs’ calculated gamble on Stolarz has become one of the franchise’s key storylines. Toronto’s decision to roll the dice on Stolarz was bold and could’ve easily backfired. Instead, it might have become a defining season for Stolarz and the Maple Leafs. Although Stolarz made a mistake on the Senators’ first goal, his composure and skill shone through.
He turned the Maple Leafs’ risky offseason call into a performance that could shape this series’ future very well. What many saw as a leap of faith from Toronto has already shown its brilliance. Toronto’s Stanley Cup journey is too young for wild speculation. That said, Stolarz’s play in Game 1 could be the foundation of a Maple Leafs’ playoff run.
Stolarz Was an Undrafted Backup Journeyman
It’s easy to forget that Stolarz was a surprise to end up anywhere in the NHL. Undrafted, he bounced around the league as a backup for much of his career. For most, the road to the NHL is paved with first-round picks and highly-touted prospects — but Stolarz? His journey has been unconventional.
In fact, when Toronto acquired him, it was seen more as a depth move—a reliable backup for the regular season and a potential playoff insurance policy. No one expected Stolarz to be the guy, let alone the one standing between the Maple Leafs and a critical Game 1 victory.
Stolarz Put Up the Best Save Percentage in the NHL This Season
But here’s the story. Stolarz didn’t just step in and play average hockey. He dominated. He finished the regular season with the best save percentage in the entire NHL. The backup who wasn’t even supposed to be the starter posted elite numbers, playing at a level that left many around the league wondering if he had found something extra.
Stolarz’s consistency throughout the season had earned him the respect of his teammates, but nobody was quite sure if it would translate to the high-pressure playoff environment. After all, postseason hockey is a different beast. And, for at least one night, Stolarz slayed the playoff dragon.
Stolarz: The Offseason Bet Is Now He’s the Maple Leafs’ Backbone
The decision to bring in Stolarz didn’t dominate headlines in the off-season. It was quiet, calculated — a depth move in the eyes of many. But now, as the playoffs begin to reveal who’s built for the moment, that move looks like one of the most important the Maple Leafs made.
Stolarz didn’t just hold the line in Game 1; he was calm under pressure, sharp on every read, and unshaken by playoff intensity. He gave the Maple Leafs exactly what they needed: belief from the crease out. He looked more like a starter than a safety net, outdueling Ottawa’s physicality and firepower and keeping Toronto firmly in control.
This wasn’t about Game 1. It was about the long game. Toronto took a chance last summer, investing in a goalie they believed could grow into something more. That belief is now blossoming into a postseason advantage — and Stolarz is proving that some of the best bets are the quiet ones.
Related: Maple Leafs Playing Ryan Reaves Is a Calculated Risk
