It feels like the Toronto Maple Leafs have seen two different versions of Joseph Woll this season. Before January 3rd, Woll was a reliable presence in the net. He compiled an impressive 12-6 record in 18 games with a 2.39 GAA and a .917 SV%. However, after January 3rd, Woll’s performance has taken a noticeable dip.
Since Early January, Woll’s Record Hasn’t Been Strong
In 16 games since then, Woll has a 9-6 record. However, he has also put up a troubling 3.25 GAA and a .891 SV%. Despite the dip in his play, the Maple Leafs’ high-powered offense had (until recently) masked his struggles. The result is that he’s been granted a respectable record even if he didn’t deserve it. However, with the postseason on the horizon, Woll will need to raise his game if the Maple Leafs are going to make a deep run.
Meanwhile, Anthony Stolarz has returned from a two-month injury absence without missing a beat. Before his injury, Stolarz posted a decisive 9-5 record, 2.15 GAA, and a .927 SV%. Since coming back, he’s been strong in the crease. He’s put up a 4-1-1 record in six games. His only loss was in a game in which he relieved Woll. Stolarz is second in the NHL this season with a .925 SV% and a 2.21 GAA. He’s playing at an elite level.

The Maple Leafs Need Both Goalies Playing Well
With 20 games remaining in the regular season over the next 36 days, the Maple Leafs will need both goaltenders to step up. But as it stands, Stolarz is playing himself into the starting role. At the same time, Woll’s recent struggles might see him move out of that position heading into the playoffs.
By the time the Maple Leafs play the Colorado Avalanche on Saturday, all trade deadline moves will be finalized. Any uncertainty surrounding players’ futures will also be put to rest. It’s time to focus on taking care of business and finishing strong as the postseason approaches.
With both goalies playing a key role, the Maple Leafs must find the right balance in the crease to make a successful run. They could be the tipping point between success and failure during the postseason.
[Note: I’d like to thank Stan Smith for his contributions to this post.]