The Toronto Maple Leafs’ five-game winning streak came to an end in a 3-2 shootout loss to the San Jose Sharks, a team that had been struggling with eight straight losses. Despite holding a 2-0 lead and looking ready to close the game out, the Maple Leafs let it slip away in the third period.
After a strong second period and goals from John Tavares and Matthew Knies, the Maple Leafs couldn’t seal the deal, with San Jose mounted a comeback that ultimately led to overtime and the shootout. The loss was especially disappointing given the context of playing against the last-place Sharks, and the missed opportunity to gain two points in a tightly contested playoff race.
Takeaway 1. Maple Leafs Disappointing Collapse in the Third Period
The Maple Leafs had a solid 2-0 lead heading into the third period but allowed the Sharks to claw their way back, giving up two goals in the final frame. Coach Craig Berube pointed to turnovers and a lack of proper checking as key factors in the breakdown.
Despite a late power play opportunity in overtime, the Maple Leafs couldn’t capitalize. As a result, they were forced to settle for a single point after a lackluster performance in the shootout.
Takeaway 2. Matthew Knies Continues His Strong Play
Matthew Knies extended his hot streak. He scored his 24th goal of the season, once again finding the back of the net in the dying minutes of a period. He seems to have a way to score late.
Knies power-play goal, which came late in the second, gave the Maple Leafs a two-goal cushion. Knies has consistently parked himself in front of the net. From that vantage point, he’s shown the ability to screen the goalie, tip pucks, and clean up rebounds. The young winger’s physicality and courage near the crease continue to make him a dangerous scorer for his team.
Takeaway 3. The Maple Leafs Missed Chances and Executed Poorly
While the Maple Leafs did some things right, including their power play, which contributed two goals, several missed opportunities proved costly. Toronto’s shots missed the net over and over again. On top of that, Mitch Marner’s breaking his stick in the shootout didn’t help. It was a crucial bit of bad luck that showed how the game could swing on small details.
The Maple Leafs had a chance to extend their lead throughout the game, but they failed to close it out. Sadly, it came back to bite them.

The Bottom Line: A Bitter Loss, But Not the End of the Season
The Maple Leafs’ 3-2 shootout loss to the Sharks was a tough pill to swallow, especially when they were in control of the game but failed to finish. With a busy schedule ahead, including a three-game road trip starting Wednesday against the Golden Knights, Toronto must sharpen up in all areas, especially in third-period play and finishing chances.
With all this said, the Maple Leafs are still tied for the lead in the Atlantic Division with a game in hand, which puts them in a strong position. However, they lost one game they should have won. Fans should see this perhaps as a glass half full rather than half empty. After a grueling schedule, where the team won games they should’ve lost, the chickens came home to roost last night. That’s too bad, but that’s how professional hockey in the NHL goes.
The Maple Leafs remain in a strong position, but this loss reminds us how thin the margin for error is in the tight playoff race.
Related: Five Curious Facts About Maple Leafs’ 6-5 OT Win Over Penguins